Pages

Friday, July 13, 2012

Lawrence of Arabia

1962. 216 Minutes.
“He was the most extraordinary man I ever knew.”

No doubt the history of the movie and the acting of Peter O’Toole speak for themselves in the annals of film making. I revisited the film for my interest in the Middle East and because every once in a while I just have a craving to watch an old flick. I was perhaps not as impressed as I was a few years ago when I first viewed the movie. I should say that I was impressed for different reasons. I was excited for the biographical narrative that was unfolding through the spectacular cinematography, the story of an esoteric figure journeying where few others would willingly go; for the triumphal music of Lawrence marching into the desert; but most of all, for the psychological portrayal of T.E. Lawrence, whose exhaustive trek across the sands of the Arabian peninsula, I see now, come at a price.

What also intrigued me was Lawrence’s ability to be a discreet politician. His passion for the Arabs, his knowledge of Arabic (only subtly referenced in the movie), and his ability to understand the psychological aspects of conflicting tribes, make his personality great. But this also makes the movie great. The viewer is staring at a tapestry of stories woven into one film. The result is not triumphant like the ride into the desert, or like the conquests of another youthful twenty-seven year old in Alexander the Great. Instead, the viewer is intrigued by the modern day appropriations of one man’s ability to unite and conquer with a mix of brain and might, a cocktail conspicuously absent in our own time.

While Lawrence is a mysterious man, there is no mistaken that fifty years after the premier of the film, the personality and result of his efforts are shrouded in the same uncertainty and mystery today as they were in Lawrence’s own time. All we need do to appreciate Lawrence’s effort in uniting the Arab League, is to look at the modern day Middle East. Unification and peace is a difficult task for a whole nation to broker, never mind the effort of one man.

More important than anything else, the viewer can appreciate the audacity of Lawrence’s desire to make a change, to make peace, and to manipulate and negotiate with subtle and overt powers. Lawrence engages in the “mechanism of power” by uniting one twig with five and again with twenty to hold a whole house aloft (the power of many from one). Watching Lawrence lead and reign with what many called crazy ideas, we can appreciate the revolt that precipitated the Arab Spring, the Occupy Movement, and the need to ignite the impossible. This makes Lawrence of Arabia impressive and wholly modern, but also bold. Yes, BOLD. Is how we might describe the personality and the film as we apply present attributes to a sweeping epic. Even in failure.

It was Lawrence, many would argue, who failed in his task to unite the Arabs. The question of Lawrence’s failure is framed so brilliantly by the director. It was Lawrence’s (O’Toole) exhaustion and disdain, his resignation from the desert, that was created so boldly and dramatically at the direction of David Lean. What really makes Lawrence of Arabia so great is the strong, complex cast of supporting characters. It was, after all, the acting of Alec Guinness as Prince Feisel who made a believer out of me. It was a convincing Anthony Quinn playing Auda Abu Tayi who made Lawrence’s maniacal heroics believable and possible. The direction and supporting cast made me realize that the film is a study in high artistic drama. It paves the way for brilliant and epic filmmakers by the likes of Spielberg and Lucas. David Lean is the first in a long line of directors who bring character and brilliance in a union that makes biographical narrative dance with the breath of the stars. The direction and the acting makes anything possible. And that is what we want: a reality that becomes fantasy as we strive for greatness. The movie is, after all, greatness. And that’s just what we need: epic greatness in pursuit of a better world. Artistically it is, anyway.

*Originally written for The Big Brown Chair




Monday, July 9, 2012

Atonement

2007. 123 Minutes. Rated R.
“Come back. Come back to me.”

The film is composed like Stieglitz’s “Steerage” photograph: a view filled with abstraction, happenstance and the consequence of class, bad luck and a passage that is separated by two distinct journeys. The direction of Joe Wright makes a complex narrative appear so simple. Like Stieglitz taking a “shot” at a complex narrative in one frame, Wright composes an equally difficult piece with the same variation and excitement. In what appears as a movie that by all accounts should come unraveled, it stands tall in affirming its place among the dramatic giants.

This is what earns Wright great acclaim: he taps into every moving part to complement each other, even if working in opposite directions. Atonement, then, becomes a mechanical masterpiece. The dissonant cinematography rolls against the accompaniment of a careful music that enhances the sequence. When the cinematography is picturesque, Wright changes direction to orchestrate a dissonant music. All the parts of the film roll against each other, somehow making it work and somehow enhancing the emotional storyline–of love, sadness and loss. If that’s not enough, the viewer is nagged by the periodic clicking (pounding) of the typewriter, a nod to the drama that is being written and re-written to unravel a dizzying tale of disbelief.

Keira Knightley is profound in her portrayal as Cecilia, a wealthy daughter living in the countryside of England who falls in love with the groundskeeper’s son, Robbie (James McAvoy). Cecilia and Robbie move in different social circles. By all accounts, this is a relationship that should never be given a chance to blossom. An accidental letter to Cecilia finds Robbie in Cecilia’s loving arms, and fuels a love story for the ages–or so it seems. Just as the two lovers are getting acquainted in their passion, a lie lands Robbie in jail. Robbie is forced to enter WWII as a field soldier while Cecilia stays behind, certain of Robbie’s innocence. She awaits this wronged ship to right itself. It never does.

The viewer, emotionally exhausted, curses little Briony Tallis (Saoirse Ronan) for her reckless imagination. An aspiring writer, Briony falsely implicates Robbie in an act for which he did not participate. Because of Briony’s lone testimony, Robbie is sent away to jail. A forbidden love on the brink of greatness now slowly comes unraveling at the seams, challenging a family’s trust, its voice and its vision of the future. The viewer is confronted with a psychological self-examination. We recount everyone in our past who has lied to us, everyone who has changed us by word or by action. And faced with Briony’s confession that “I saw him with my own eyes,” we are left philosophically weary of mankind’s intentions to “see” only what it wants to see. We are filled instantly with regret and loss. And the typewriter keeps tapping.

Atonement is as much about seeking forgiveness for all of our “human, all too human” transgressions–against mediocrity and its great, but sometimes regrettable consequences–as it is about learning to find enough room for love and understanding. The film finds us enmeshed in a cathartic tale of stupidity. We are angry, sad and at once devastated. But in the end all we can do is cry. For how much of what we do is left to circumstances beyond our control? Atonement teaches us of our delicate humanity in a life that must learn to love, forgive and heal or wash away in the world of emotional war–a wound that cuts through many and never truly heals.

It is no surprise that Atonement was nominated for an Oscar for best film. It might have won an Oscar-the-Grouch award for emotional yo-yoing. It is always hard to replace the character depth and complexity of a novel written by Ian McEwan in a two hour film; however, Joe Wright exacts his necessary toll on the human mind and leaves enough on the screen in his artistic collage to change the course of history–through film, anyway, leaving the viewer to achieve perfection, even if the film itself lacks the recipe for perfection. It is the effort that is rewarding. And that’s why we should all watch it.





*Originally written for the The Big Brown Chair

Thursday, July 5, 2012

Experiments in Education: Defining the Future

I read an article in Wired Magazine on the Stanford education experiment that could change higher education.  In the article there is a reference to the Khan Academy, a program endorsed by the likes of Bill Gates, a person who ought to know something about changing the future "course" of accepted systems. The primary challenge to the future of higher education seems to be (1) the capacity to challenge the system of formal education, and (2) the idea that one body needs to be standing in front of the classroom dictating knowledge, what has been called the "sage on the stage" model.

The idea of online courses has in many ways changed the way we learn, but by opening up the classroom, learning has been radically transformed to a truly egalitarian model that embraces a desire around the rest of the world to hear and learn from the most enlightened thinkers and educators.  While a huge hurdle to this project seems to be the reach of dependable Internet access around the world, the principle of interactive and ubiquitous learning is an idea that is fundamental to the credo of all teachers and professors, similar to the Hippocratic Oath for doctors.  These models cannot be done by everyone, but can be shared for all.  Not only is technology making it easier to access information but also to integrate lessons through the use of other technology - interactive, simple and engaging, as any Khan Academy tutorial will attest.

What I expect (hope) from the revolutionary model of higher education freeing itself from the shackle of privilege and cost, is a revolution in access. We are there in the model and principle of open access.  But as I have written before, this model has to transcend all boundaries of information - books, journals and the frontier of all education.  Only then can we truly talk about the global commons and a shared value system around the world.  The reach of all aspects of education must be realizable and sustainable for all, regardless of economic status, as fundamental to a global constitution as healthcare and clean running water.   How it will be modeled - through government funding or outside subsidiaries - will shape its future. This is opportunity.


Wednesday, May 23, 2012

The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo


2011. 158 min. Rated R
“She's different in every way.”
I’m not high on crime thrillers, but this movie was exceptional in its execution. I had no expectations, since I did not read the novel on which the movie was based. I also did not see the original Swedish movie which, in some ways, made me a perfect candidate for seeing the Hollywood version of the film, without bias or preconceived notions for how the film ought to unfold. I am not a purist, thinking that certain films are a sacrilege. The most important part of the film for me is spreading access to the thrilling Stieg Larsson trilogy.  The recipe for The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is carefully communicated by executing the plot through good acting and careful cinematography. This film has it all.  And I became a fan, enthralled by the expert choreography of direction.
Mikael Blomkvist (Daniel Craig) is the disgraced journalist, trying to resuscitate his career after a sloppy report construed as libel, threatens to land him in jail. A wealthy patriarch by the name of Henrik Vanger (Chrisopher Plummer) commissions Mikael to investigate the disappearance of a niece, nearly forty years ago on an island north of Stockholm. Mikael agrees to take the case, a chance to prove his worth and renew his good name.  With the help of Lisbeth Salander (Rooney Mara), Mikael seeks to recover more than a lost story and a lost body.  He wants to recover his career.
Daniel Craig, best known for his role as Bond in the new iteration of James Bond, teams up with the punked out psycho-case, Lisbeth, a project of the state being monitored for her perceived mental instability. Lisbeth is left in the care of a step-father who is suddenly incapacitated by a stroke. Lisbeth is placed in the "care" of another, attorney Nils Bjurman. Bjurman’s primary role is to monitor Lisbeth’s mental health through the submission of monthly reports. Bjurman agrees to submit reports outlining Lisbeth's progress and mental competence, in exchange for sexual favors. What ensues is one of the most gruesome rape scenes in the history of cinema. This sets up a relationship that does not end well for “Nils @#$!ing Bjurman” and precipitates Lisbeth’s desire to make anyone who crosses her path with malicious intent, pay.
Mikael and Lisbeth, a most unlikely pair, are teamed up when Mikael, seeking help with his search, learns of Lisbeth’s part-time investigative work through a man by the name of Armansky. Mikael entices Lisbeth with the case as they both seek to put their recent difficulties behind them, placing all of their energy into a case no one has been able to solve. Lisbeth, a master computer hacker who struggles with her sociability, is a perfect candidate to help solve the riddle of the missing girl. She uses her computer prowess to unlock decades of secrets.  The investigation is ripe with all the trappings of Lisbeth’s own nightmare upbringing and recent abuses, making the events of the case all the more intriguing, or thrilling.
The film is intense. And while there is no mistake that a pierced, tattooed outsider has made its way into our mainstream culture, she has made her way into our hearts--sort of. While there is some ambivalence about Lisbeth's character, there is no uncertainty over the thrilling ride that is created at Daniel Fincher's direction. He orchestrates a masterpiece of suspense, crime, and mystery.  The film unfolds like a Rembrandt masterpiece, heavy on the chiaroscuro (the tonal contrast), deep in character profile, and profound in emotional subtlety.  Daniel Craig is raw, honest and believable, while Rooney Mara is a natural study in misfit ingenuity.  The viewer longs for a connection to Lisbeth, but instead opts for a communion in solving a case and redefining the hidden miseries of past sufferings. Together they comprise a Biblical upheaval and resurrection among investigators, atoning for a lost path that is slowly but surely reconstructed.  Until the next installment.
After watching the film, I made sure to read the Millennium Trilogy in its entirety.  I stand behind my observations that The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is a must see.  With the careful oversight of the director and the intense but subtle acting combined with the cult feel of this thriller, the film will be viewed as a classic in years to come.


*Originally written for TheBigBrownChair

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

A Closer Look at the Bibliotheca Alexandrina

I have been working with the Bibliotheca since January and I have taken little opportunity to photograph the facility until now. A few weeks ago I took extensive pictures of both the exterior and interior of the library complex. I did not take pictures of the Museum space, which in some ways is a separate facility, though extremely nice. I also did not take a picture of the United Nations collection or the Manuscript Library. I hope to add those pictures in a separate post. The library is a huge facility and has so many moving parts, including the Digital Lab and separate collections. While I love the architecture of the library, I have had a hard time understanding some of the decisions made by the architects. Some of the space, in my opinion, is not utilized well. Even the idea of a building with four (4) floors below ground is strange. The Arts and Multimedia library, for example, is located in Basement 3 (B3), three floors below entrance level. There are no windows and, as you might imagine, Internet access is painfully slow in some areas.

The Mediterranean with the Bibliotheca in the background

Snøhetta, a Norwegian Architectural firm, was awarded the design of the library, which was officially inaugurated in 2002 at a cost of well over $220 million. The library is not that old and quite spectacular in conception and realization.

The idea of the library rising at an angle (16 degrees) was purposely designed to replicate the rising of the sun, a symbolic gesture signaling the library as a center of learning, looking back to the legacy of the Ancient Library of Alexandria. The library (the sun) rises over the city and ordains learning and intellectual pursuit as that which lights all of humanity. The Planetarium, then, is the moon which rotates around the sun.
The library and accompanying structures used to be magnificently lit at night so that the whole orchestrated complex looked like some kind of vast solar system. Because of budgetary constraints, the buildings are no longer lit with the glowing blue light, or any light for that matter, leaving a void on the horizon when looking across the city to the area of the Bibliotheca.

What is not known from the photos, is that the public square, or plaza, located around the front and side of the library gets extremely crowded on any given day. In fact, it is a mob scene everyday I leave work. Many of the students from the University of Alexandria use the Bibliotheca as their university library. This signals a problem of sorts for Egypt, that there is no university or public library system in the country. I wish I could communicate the number of times I wanted to stop at a public library while visiting Cairo to use a computer, read a magazine and relax in front of books and CDs. I am spoiled by the place of the public library in the US.

Below is a series of forty-four (44) pictures of the library, inside and out, with appropriate explanation. Many of my pictures leave something to be desired. Hopefully I can follow-up with another post showing different views and collections of the library. In the meantime, Enjoy!

*By the way, the whole library facility closes daily at 4:30PM. A movement to extend the library hours until 7:00PM was not approved.


The Outside


There is a number of different script and scribble on the side of the stone facade that, while individually meaningless, symbolizes the language from all over the world. You can see some of the script in the semblance of hieroglyphs and Chinese characters and different drawings/markings. The gray granite from Aswan (Upper Egypt) displays the letters (not words) from the alphabets of some 120 languages.

The above ground portion of the Bibliotheca

A detail of the Bibliotheca wall

The pictures also reveal a pedestrian bridge that cuts across (pierces, is more like it) the main facade of the building, allowing pedestrians to “participate” in the structure from above, and ruminate on the origins of a system they participate in creating and utilizing.

Library Rising from the Sea

The Rising Library from Afar

The windows seen on the “slant” of the library were created to symbolize eyes, the window to the rest of the world, waking with the rising of the sun, allowing light on the spirit of mankind in their pursuit of knowledge and truth. The windows from the inside are covered in blue and green glass to symbolize the natural light from the sky. While the windows do not provide any significant amount of natural light, it does provide a relaxing ambiance through the use of color to alternately signify the sky and the sea, a meeting of the heavens and the earth colliding as the sun rises and retreats, opening and closing to those who pursue its riches inside.
The appearance from the Mediterranean is a glowing disk moving in subtle relation to the sky.

Approaching the Rising Library

Approaching the Library

It is noticeable in some of the pictures that there is an area for water to surround the library building. This is for natural rain water, but also for regularly running fountains. The library surrounded with water further emphasized the effect of the sun rising from the sea (as in looking across the Mediterranean to a sunrise). It is also stated that the water creates a “floating” of the building out of reach of the surroundings. As with the lighting of the complex at night, diminishing funds have eliminated the continuous flow of water that would ordinarily surround the complex.

Another View Approaching the Rising Library

Main Entrance to the Library

Ismail Serageldin in his book on the library, notes that even the discreet entrance of the Bibliotheca recalls the traditions of Mamluk Cairo, the entering of large and beautiful buildings through discreet and/or broken entrances that does not reveal the full size or splendor of the architecture.

*Ismail Serageldin was recently nominated into the American Academy of Arts and Sciences. A great achievement for Dr. Serageldin, and the Bibliotheca.

Main Entrance to the Library

Staff Entrance to the Bibliotheca

Approaching the Main Entrance from South

The Conference Center, located just across from the Main Entrance to the Library, is a place where many conferences take place in addition to lectures and some concerts. There is also an auditorium inside the main library, but the conference center allows for more formal affairs to take place. Just last week there was a week-long BioVision conference on sustainability, health care and the environment. I also attended a lecture on art in the Coptic Monasteries.

The Conference Center Across from the Main Entrance

Conference Center, Library, Plaza from Above

Planetarium and Conference Center

View of the Plaza in front of the Staff Entrance

The Planetarium acts as a sphere that orbits in tandem with the rising sun. The orb has an entrance accessible via a stairway that leads underground, giving the entrance a sci-fi, subterranean feel of entering another world, similar, I would say, to the feeling of entering the catacombs. The other-worldly feel is confirmed by the interior space and the displays/shows that confirm that feeling of transport to another world. The mobility and interaction of the complex is confirmed by placement of the planetarium within proximity to the conference center and the rising library. In other words, the complex is interactive, calling for visitors to “negotiate” the space.

View of the Planetarium and the Mediterranean Sea

A View of the Plaza and Planetarium from Above

The library complex is located right off of the Corniche, the main thoroughfare that follows the Mediterranean Sea the entire length of the city. The plaza of the library is also covered with sculptures donated to the library through the ongoing resident artist program that for years has been a staple of the Bibliotheca. To the side of the plaza, overlooking the Planetarium and the rising library, is a series of food shops, a couple of coffee shops and a bookstore, Diwan Books. All have a second floor seating area where visitors can order a coffee and look out at the plaza, the library and the Mediterranean. I often frequent the cafes to take in the spectacular view and play tourist for an hour or two, as I sip on my espresso and marvel at the complexity and integrity of the facility.

A View of the Plaza in Front of the Bibliotheca

A View of the Mediterranean from the Library Plaza


The Inside


The Arts Library is located on B3, or the third Basement. There is also another part of the 3rd Basement that extends beyond the Arts library. The third floor also houses the religion collection and a computer lab used for electronic resource instruction. I used the electronic resource classroom once to share resources in the Arts. It took me a while to really find my way around the whole Bibliotheca.

Labeling the Floors

Looking up to the Rising Floors

It might not be entirely apparent by looking at my pictures, but the interior levels create a tiered effect that seems to replicate the exterior of the Temple of Queen Hatshepsut. Many of the architectural features play on the traditions of Egyptian sculpture and architecture, including the use of different types of stone from the region in producing a desired affect inside the library.

Intricate Details on the Rising Floors

Some of the thin concrete columns that flower outward near the top recall the hypostyle temples of Luxor, but also recall the “flowering” of knowledge while paying tribute to the papyrus theme evident in ancient Egyptian architecture. The thin columns also blossom into what appears like Islamic arches (not visible in the pictures), combining Pharaonic columns and Islamic arches, a combination of architectural traits evident throughout the library. In any case, the forms are simple, merging the past, the present and the future in a hybrid design.

Staircase from the Basement to Upper Floors

The staircases that lead to the first, or main, floor are royal in their appearance. It showcases the Queen Hatshepsut feel of royalty that presides over all knowledge.

Two Floating Seminar Rooms Linked by Bridges

Open Space on Lower Floor

Study Space Against the Intricate Shape of the Library

Periodical Reading Room

One of Many Exhibitions Throughout the Library

Print Machines on B1

Old Printing Press

Looking at the Wall from the Maps Library

The black granite seen on the walls surrounding the staircases is a special granite imported from Zimbabwe. It is said to be of particularly strong character. Also notable in a few of the pictures is an oxidized brass paneling that naturally reduces noise. In some locations there is a green wall covering. The covering is a plastic made in Austria. It gives a sheen, finished granite/marble appearance in line with the finished look of the rest of the interior. The green plastic is strategically placed to offer additional coloring, mimicking the green light in the “eyelash” design of the ceiling windows. The oxidized brass paneling can be seen behind the reference desk in the Arts library, while the green stone walls are quite obvious in a number of pictures. The green walls also recall the water of the Mediterranean, which most days appears to be the color of absinthe.

Looking up from Basement Floor Number 4

From the Maps and Periodical Library


While there seems to be a thought that there is not much criticism of the library architecture, I am somewhat critical of the space. The wood flooring throughout the library is not conducive to the type of quiet comfort one might expect from a library. I am also not a fan of four (4) basement floors, eliminating the presence of windows, and thus, a connection with nature and the natural world. While Dr. Serageldin commented that one of the few criticisms of the building is the failed opportunity for applying solar panels to the roof, the space in the middle of the library is not utilized as well as it could be.


The Arts Library

Reading Reference Room in the Arts Library


Reading Reference Room in the Arts Library


I love the picture of the Reference Desk in the Arts Library. The desk is always ridiculously busy, especially with students from the University. I love the picture of Oum Kalthum, the feisty and powerful Egyptian singer with a voice to match. The poster is symbolic of the Arts library, a feisty and well performed machine that keeps rolling out a distinguished model of service and programming. Typically there is a poster to the side of the reference desk outlining the monthly film program (slightly visible in the picture). There is a film showing every Thursday at 1:00, centered around a different monthly theme. There are a number of exhibit cases that normally showcase a an exhibit within the Arts library. The cases have been clustered to the right of the reference desk for months, eagerly awaiting movement so that staff can fill the cases with meaningful exhibits to accompany the grandeur of the library.

Reference Desk in the Arts Library


Arts Periodicals

On a number of occasions I have worked in the Arts reading room. I get better Internet connection in the reading room and have learned to appreciate being surrounded by the hum of students entering and departing the space. The wooden seats, however, are ridiculously uncomfortable. God forbid you should take a call on your cell phone. Even as an “official” employee of the library, I was almost thrown out of the library for taking a call – from the director of the Arts Library, no less!

Reading Room in the Arts Library


The Arts Library


The number of books in the Arts library is impressive. I can’t remember the last time I saw this many art related items in one place. I did not bring many books with me for teaching. Thankfully, I was able to find most of what I needed in the stacks.

Stacks inside the Arts Library


I happen to love the massive concrete columns in the library, though I can’t really articulate why. The massive columns only appear in some areas, the Arts library is one of them. I guess it gives the space a sense of grandeur while combining the modern with the traditional in one form. I also love the number of sculptures and displays scattered throughout the library. I am constantly “interacting” with the library. It keeps the mind active and the body moving in and around the library: a place that should never be passive – in theory, anyway.

The Arts Library


Study Space and Courtyard from the Arts Library


This is one of the programming rooms used for talks and readings. There are about four (4) proper lecture rooms. The perimeter of the Arts library has private viewing rooms for students to watch films or meet for group study.

Theater Room inside the Library


The building and complex are certainly worthy of the 2004 Aga Khan architectural award, as the structure is brilliantly unique. Some details of all brilliant architecture, however, are usually overlooked in favor of the splendor of the overall design. The network of elevators and stairs, for example, are not very efficient when trying to get from one location to another. The presence of one bathroom on the bottom floor of the library for an entire building of patrons is comical, and in walking the network of stairways, there is an external opening on conjoining floors that could cause someone to get their whole leg trapped or break a foot while climbing the stairways. Because of the disk structure to the building, everything is created in a hierarchical scheme that expands or eliminates space based on the floor in which the collection presides. This means that if the structure was not built on a 16 degree angle, the space on each floor would be equal, and allow for a more appropriate apportioning of space for expanding collections. I imagine what the space might look like if each floor was equal in size from bottom to top. After I think about it, though, I disagree with my other self and feel that the Bibliotheca as it stands is remarkably unique. All practicalities aside, I could argue the faults of any structure. For its sheer brilliance and monumentality, the Bibliotheca really is a beautiful sight to behold. I am quite fortunate to have entered the library nearly everyday for almost 6 months. And I agree with other comments that the Bibliotheca is like a living museum in which scholars are able to actively interact through the wealth of resources and exhibits that, like the architecture, create a continual dialogue. As long as the complex keeps us talking and searching, how can we argue with the end result?

Sculpture in the main entrance of the Bibliotheca


Interestingly, the library complex is a merging of architectural forms from the past, a merging of classical Egyptian and Greek ideas about learning, astronomy, space, and the intricate workings that create an integrated union between men and women of learning, the universe that surrounds them and that keeps them curious and engaged. This is a resolution of my criticism above (continual engagement)

Here are some further details for all those interested. There is so much to write about the space, and the experience of the library, but I am forced to confine my observations. Here is a link to Snøhetta, the Norwegian architectural firm’s Account of the Building.

It is also useful to read the works of the director, Ismail Serageldin (still director despite recent calls that he be fired).
“A Landmark Building: Reflections on the Architecture of the Bibliotheca Alexandrina.” Bibliotheca Alexandrina Publication, 2006.

Here also is an overview from the Aga Khan Development Network

Monday, April 30, 2012

eBooks and eResources: Financing a Limit


I have been following the advance of ebooks with some interest. I was an early adopter of ereaders by default.  My mother gave me an early Sony Reader.  While happy to use it, I was a little annoyed that I had to download an ebook to my computer then hook the ereeader up to download the book.  This seemed cumbersome and unnecessary. 

I have had an iPad for a while and I have been frustrated with the inability to use the Kindle app to download books directly from Amazon.  This is a feature of Amazon’s proprietary practices.  While amazon is not the only option, most other ebooks available online depend on a browser to download a book, an antiquated model that has not been liberated by the introduction of the tablet or ereader.

Recently, our library has been ordering ebooks for our collection that are only usable with a tablet since they must be opened from a browser.  The ebooks through our catalog are not compatible with most ereaders, rendering such devices fairly useless. This is not to mention that there is a little consistency with a single place, in either our catalog, or a consolidated database, for housing and accessing the titles. 

Recently, I have noticed that while we are part of a consortium, our efforts and intentions to share materials have been limited (thwarted) by the purchase of ebooks.  Most ebooks are only readable by the purchasing institution.  I cannot, for example, read books purchased by another library in our consortium that purchased the ebook.  It says in the catalog “Access for ______ students only.”  This is a problem I have noticed recently while our institution was in the process of “gifting” a collection of OverDrive titles to our consortium.  The ebooks for purchase via OverDrive are accessible to anyone in the consortium who has a library card.  I requested copies of books that were already “available” in the catalog from other libraries in our region, but not "accessible" because of the limitations of access.  There are still limits to lending from OverDrive that are quite frustrating too.  There is a four (4) item limits to borrowing from OD.  I have to balance a couple of books for my kids with something of interest for the adult user.  I have also noticed that formats in OverDrive are available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle, but our consortium does not purchase titles in PDF.  Really I can only check out one  (EPUB) with my iPad anyway.  I have a Kindle I “inherited” last year that has 3G and wireless.  I can’t download OverDrive books or any other online books with it.  I know it is slightly different with the Kindle Fire.  It just amazes me that anyone would purchase an ereader since a tablet is almost a necessity, even for reading in the current ebook climate. 

Our shared collection in OverDrive also does not allow us to purchase nor access films.  And while we have resources from a number of different databases such as “Films on Demand”, and music from “Naxos”, the expense and limits of access are quite apparent.  This is a problem I have been communicating with staff at the Bibliotheca.  While I was reviewing resources in a workshop today, and discussing some of the problems with access,  I was told by the head of the Arts library that she has been trying to build a music library through electronic resources; she has been told that it would cost $500,000.00.  She needs help appealing to a wealthy benefactor to support the resources.  I am on the hunt to help, mostly finding new, less constricting ways to access resources, especially the library's growing interest in ebooks. I am also looking for ways other libraries can access material, equitably, around the world.  The disparity is most evident in the purchasing of electronic resources.  This is not a model that is sustainable around the world.  Even an institution as storied and expansive as the Bibliotheca Alexandrina cannot afford access to the modest reservoir of knowledge available and affordable at my state university.  I am not sure how long an institution like the Bibliotheca can depend on the limited generosity of publishers and vendors to support its goals and missions.  Something has to change. 

Wednesday, April 18, 2012

The Descendants

 2011. 115 minutes. Rated R.






"What is it that makes the women in my life destroy themselves?"

The Descendants, directed by Alexander Payne, features the bittersweet drama of Matt King (George Clooney), a Hawaii attorney and land owner, who struggles to reconcile the imminent loss of his wife after a boating accident with his new role as a single father of two girls. Matt King learns that his wife Elizabeth, (Patricia Hastle) who is in a coma, will not live. Learning of an affair she had with a real estate magnate, Matt and his daughters mount an "investigation" of sorts to get some closure. What might be construed as a tearjerker is instead a funny, bright and sobering drama of a father and his two girls connecting with one another as they unearth the secrets of Elizabeth's love affair, and begin to mourn the loss of a life they knew, even if not embraced. And while a story of loss might be heavy on the emotions, it is instead unapologetically human in its portrayal of frailty, humor, awkwardness and dysfunction; the trademarks of every family struggling to come to terms with events of a unexpected family drama.

As the news of Elizabeth's coma turns into a story of loss, Matt King is readying for a decision about the selling of  of land owned by the family estate. An old law against perpetuity requires land owned by Matt's side of the family to be sold or risk losing it altogether. As sole trustee, Matt presides over the decision of who to sell 25,000 acres of land. If the land falls to the "wrong" bidder, a hidden paradise could turn into a modern day eyesore. The island eagerly awaits his decision.
Matt King comes from a wealthy family and, as a result,  is independently wealthy, sitting on a separate trust he never touches. His siblings and cousins have burned through their trusts and seek to gain through the sale of the family land.  Matt's wealth becomes a subplot for a life that is flashing before him at the reminders of his cousins and friends. If only Elizabeth was given more money for shopping sprees, she wouldn't have been in the boat seeking the thrills of the waves when she fell. It is also presumed that King doesn't need to capitalize on the sale of the land, and can take less to sell to a local buyer. So go the whispers of the townsfolk.
Amidst the "drama" around the sale of the land and the news that Elizabeth's Will dictates that she be taken off life support, Matt, at the urging of his eldest daughter, Alexandra King (Shailene Woodley), decides to track down Elizabeth's lover. After all, it was Alex who, fresh home from boarding school to see her mother, informs Matt that his wife was having an affair.
What ensues in the hunt for a man involved in Elizabeth's affair, is a short journey into the hearts and minds of a family struggling to deal with anger, conflict and sadness while finding ways to mourn by probing for answers (answers that are not always there). Like any person and family confronted with crisis, there is a moment of stress and struggle, but also a Buddhist moment of clarity that surfaces amidst the humor and comedy of the family's pursuits.
George Clooney is so smooth. He always creates a calm connection with his audience as a cool-under-pressure kind of actor. Clooney to me is sort of an academic carpenter: classy and severe, but virile and intelligent even if a bit clumsy in his discovery. In any case, he is outright comforting. And while we hold back tears a couple of times, we see the fragility and desperation, the intensity and sadness in the face of Clooney's character. Good god, he is downright spectacular as Matt King.
What comes at the end of the film is a reconciliation of sorts. Us with our family for being so goddamned complex and dysfunctional, but more appropriately, a reconciliation with our own humanity. Philosophical, light and humorous may best describe the turns and tempo of the drama. What more could I ask for? And the occasional curve ball makes this movie less than predictable. While we might believe we are familiar with the drama, we are delighted at the sheer wonder of the film's humanity. Just when we think the characters (ourselves) are incapable of clarity and forgiveness in the decisions that affect us all, we may, like Clooney, be pleasantly surprised at what unfolds.
*Written for The Big Brown Chair